Grilled Cheese Pizzaiola

I recently went on a kick making a variety of different grilled cheese sandwiches after finding myself with more bread on hand that I would normally ever eat in a week. Cheese is obviously a big part of Italian cuisine, and being such a fan of Italian food, of course I had to come up with an Italian version of the grilled cheese sandwhich. This version is inspired by a dish from Naples called steak pizzaiola, which is basically a cut of beef simmered in a “pizza” sauce.

We start with two pieces of sliced Italian bread, seeded or unseeded at your pleasure. A nice sourdough bread would also be tasty no doubt. Each slice is going to get a smear of tomato sauce.

You should choose a thick, robust sauce for this, not a watery or plain sauce. Jarred or canned pizza sauces would work, as pizza sauces tend to be more robustly seasoned and thicker in consistency than some other tomato sauces for pasta. I had a jar of Emeril's kicked-up garlic that I used a bit of this last time, but any bold sauce like a fra diavolo should be just fine. Consider reducing the sauce in a pan for a while to make it thicker. If all you have is a plain sauce on hand, simmer and reduce, adding extra seasonings, oregano, heavy on the garlic, some black and crushed red pepper. You won't need much sauce for this though, so you can refrigerate the rest for use some other time.

Now lay down a nice thick slice of provolone cheese onto a slice of bread. Mild rather than a sharp or “picante” would be best, nice and creamy. At the deli I ask them to always slice the cheese thick, as it stays in one piece better when you try to peel a slice off the top, and is better for sandwiches such as this one. Meats on the other hand, I always like as thin as possible. A regular sandwich I would sort of “ripple” or “fluff” several slices of meat for a thicker sandwich, but for this application, one thin slice of roast beef will be plenty. The cheese is really the star of the show, and the beef an accent. I used regular rare roast beef, but some delis have Italian-style roast beef that might be put to good use here with its bold flavor. Again though, one thin slice should do. Now top with one more thick round of provolone.

I tried this sandwich using store-bought packaged mozzarella, and it did not work out well at all. Far too rubbery, the whole chunk of cheese just came sliding out when I bit into it. Some fresh mozzarella might work out though, as it is creamier but not as dense as the packaged stuff. I have yet to give that a try myself though. Besides, a nice provolone will really give you a lot of flavor anyhow.

Now go ahead and lay the other slice of bread on top, sauced side down, to complete the assembly. But on the top side, we will put a nice smear of softened butter all the way to the edges. Not too thick, but cover the slice completely.

In a pan, melt another pat of butter so that it is coated nicely. Keep the heat low. When the butter is melted and bubbling some, lay the sandwich in dry side down, and let it sop up the butter in the pan. Keep the heat low. You can't rush a good grilled cheese. We don't want it to burn before the cheese has had a chance to melt. Keeping an eye on the edges of the bread, the residue in the pan, and by sense of smell, I can usually guess when it has gotten to be a perfect golden brown. I lift it and take a peek through a slotted turner. If it is perfect, go ahead and flip it onto the other side that was buttered beforehand.

When it is done, you should be left with a crispy, buttery crust on the outside, with a gooey, cheesy, robustly flavored filling.

Serve with a crisp, cool, green leafy salad for a light meal.

A more standard but still Italian flavored version of the grilled cheese sandwich could also be made by omitting the sauce and slice of roast beef. Instead, just use a slice or two of the cheese and sprinkle the inside with a bit of garlic powder and oregano. Cook the same way, to a nice golden brown with the cheese melted well. Serve as a sandwich, or perhaps in place of plain or regular garlic bread with your favorite Italian meal. It would also go well with a number of soups. You could also cut the sandwich into strips with a pizza wheel and serve the zesty sauce on the side for dipping, as an appetizer, or fun snack for kids.

Olive oil is not usually used when cooking in a pan, because of its low boiling temperature, it begins to smoke and burn rather quickly. But a good grilled cheese should be made at very low heat anyway so it might be worth a try here in place of the butter. It would be in keeping with traditional Italian flavors and just a bit more healthy, if one could really consider a grilled cheese sandwich healthy, lol.

The shopping list is simple: Sliced Italian-style bread, provolone cheese sliced thick, roast beef sliced thin, pizza sauce, butter.